Background of New York Times Chocolate Chip Cookies:

First published in the New York Times on July 9, 2008, this recipe took the internet by storm when David Leite experimented with baking cookie dough that had a chance to rest in the refrigerator for a given number of hours. Leite described that refrigeration allows for the dough and other ingredients to fully absorb the liquid, resulting in a drier dough baking to a better consistency. Leite shared that even Chocolate Chip Cookie inventor Ruth Wakefield noted in her 1953 Toll House Cookbook that the cookie dough is meant to be chilled overnight (a crucial piece of information that is not included in the recipe on the bags of Nestle’s chocolate morsels). Interesting stuff, huh?

How do you make the Best Chocolate Chip Cookies?

I decided to put this dough to the test for myself once and for all. I measured the flour and the sugar using a scale so that everything would be very accurate. And I baked all three versions of the cookies below on the same baking sheet lined with a silpat mat- at the same temperature- for the same amount of time.   I also rolled out the cookie dough and measured it so that it was exactly 3.25 ounces. The recipe suggests 3.5 ounces, but these still yielded a very large cookie with a slightly smaller measurement. I dotted additional chocolate chips on top of each round of cookie dough (as I do with all of my cookies… since it makes them look prettier).

After 5 hours of refrigeration, I couldn’t stand it any longer. I baked up my first cookie. It was what we like to call, “a very good chocolate chip cookie.” Nothing super special though.

After 24 hours, we pretty much had the same reaction as the first. It was good. Nothing to alert the media about.

For some reason, the magic seemed to happen around hour 48. The cookie dough was more crumbly and dry, as Leite mentioned in his article. The result of the baked cookie was a crispy edge with a softer interior. The key to making them perfect is to take them out of the oven when they’re golden brown on the edges and still look slightly doughy in the middle. As they set on the cooling rack, they transform into the perfect cookie.

Well, they’re made with cake flour and bread flour- two ingredients that people don’t typically stock in their kitchen. I really have no idea how they’d turn out if you tried to sub all-purpose flour, but my instinct is that the measurements would be different and they just wouldn’t turn out the same. They’re topped with a sprinkle of sea salt- I used a flaky sea salt. It’s not overwhelming, just a little sea salt sprinkled on top. My kiddo didn’t care for the salt on top, so I made a few without. My husband and I enjoyed the occasionally salty bite that you get as you make your way through eating the cookie. For the rest of the dough, I went with 2 ounce balls of cookie dough- about the size of a normal golf ball. I found that you still get the same result with a crispy edge and soft interior. And it’s not an overwhelming size for most people to eat. Are they the best chocolate chip cookie ever? Perhaps… though I’m not entirely sure. I really love my Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies and my Secret Ingredient Chocolate Chip Cookies too. One of these days I’ll have to put all three side-by-side in a blind taste test to see which one truly takes the prize for best chocolate chip cookie ever.